I have a dream (commentaire texte)

926 mots 4 pages
I have a dream 2
(2ème partie du speech de MLK)

(Commentaire préparé pour l'oral d'anglais au bac, texte divisé en 2 parties)

Intro

This is a speech by blablabla (auteur / date / lieu)
Resituer contexte (Civil Rights movement / 1964 Civil Rights Act)
Annoncer plan (First I will explain… Then/Second I will discuss/develop/present...)

I/ Acknowledgement of the situation in 1963

The reality of segregation and racism :
l.7-8 => MLK talks about "the heat of oppression"
l.9-10 => people are still judged according to the colour of their skin.
-> this is true in 1963. Although there has been some improvements, some changes in the situation (1954 Brown vs Board of Education + ...), segregation is still legal in 1963, and a reality in people's everyday lives (voir cours pour les détails)

Moreover, some states refused the new laws imposing desegregation in certains fields cf "interposition" and "nullification" (l.13) (concepts à expliquer, voir cours)

Negative metaphors:
To give more strength to his point (= pour donner davantage de poids à ses propos), MLK uses negatives metaphors when talking about segregation and racism:
l.7 "sweltering with the heat of injustice [...] heat of oppression"
l.12 "viscious racist" governor is pictured like "having his lips dripping with the words of nullification and interposition"

Transition :
However, despite the situation, MLK still dreams of a better future. In his speech, he repeats several times "I have a dream", which is why this speech is now referred to to as "I have a dream".

II/ The dream

A/ Definition of MLK's dream

Use of positive metaphors / positive language as opposed to the negative metaphors/language when talking about present situation / present segregation / racism

brotherhood (l.6) / together (l.6) / join hands (l.14) / sisters and brothers (l.14-14)
=> dream of unity between all the Americans whatever the colour of their skin. metaphor of "the sons of former slaves"

en relation

  • Art Tat Et Pouvoir Athl Tes Noir Am Ricains Mexico 1968
    788 mots | 4 pages
  • Quelques commentaires sur le film "foren book" de jean guy de maupa
    13126 mots | 53 pages
  • Ne tirez pas sur l'oiseau moqueur
    582 mots | 3 pages
  • La ségrégation des noirs aux Etats Unis
    1381 mots | 6 pages
  • L'argumentation dans jean-claude rouge brifin
    1024 mots | 5 pages
  • Commentaire de i have a dream, martin luther king
    899 mots | 4 pages
  • I have a dream
    331 mots | 2 pages
  • pme 1 haha
    2567 mots | 11 pages
  • I have a dream
    1047 mots | 5 pages
  • MIALM
    369 mots | 2 pages
  • Synthèse sur le rêve
    1208 mots | 5 pages
  • Peut-on se mentir à soi-même ?
    626 mots | 3 pages
  • La séduction du modèle américain ( incomplet )
    433 mots | 2 pages
  • Dissertation: le racisme
    723 mots | 3 pages
  • Représentation du fonctionnement de l’économie
    2186 mots | 9 pages